There is a bit of deforming, that would be ok. I guess that would happen over time on the die. Any ideas on where to source a punch for this?Does he really need a die inside the tube? In the pics it sure looks like the tube is deformed down a bit at the ends of the slot, to me saying there was no die inside the tube. Just a sharp punch will shear the long edges (both of them) using the side of the tube itself as a "die" with a little dishing going across to the other side? Besides, where would the inside die go, the slot is right up to the tube edge.