What's new
What's new

Advice on first time being burned

Ton's of great responses, thanks guys! I started to quote a bunch of you to respond and realized I seriously couldn't begin to respond to nearly everyone.

I know this is something that most all shops go through, and I have been very careful over the last 12 years. Maybe too careful, which is why my business has grown as slow as it has. That is OK with me, most days.

I am extremely, extremely fortunate, that my wife does know this stuff in and out. Her job is managing people who manage hundreds of millions of dollars in deductions. We also have health insurance and a steady income because of her :willy_nilly:

So to those of you who said, be patient, don't lose sleep, it's probably an accounting error, thanks. I have already lost sleep over this, and I shouldn't have. Inept people rub me the wrong way, because I try to know everything I can about what I am doing to be the best that I can at what I am doing. I forget that, that, is not most people.

The good news is, at the same time I was making the post, my wife was making another terse, business lingo'd email. Total we've made 4 phone calls, and this was the 3rd or 4th email.

We got a response this afternoon that stated there was some confusion on their part and they were working to find a way to fix it.

Sounds like an innocent accounting error. Am I going to hold my breath? No. But here is to hoping.
 
This happens to me about twice a year.

What I have found to do is to treat them just like they treat you. Meaning dont use the pointy finger saying YOU DID THIS. That doesn't help, usually.

This can take up to 6 months to complete, but it is way, way cheaper then a lawyer or loosing all the work time.

And dont just flip out getting mad at them. That usually doesnt end well and usually hurts your chance of getting any money. You also loose some of yourself getting so mad at things out of your control. For example, dont be mad, punch a brick wall, then get mad that the brick wall fucked your hand up and punch the wall again. Nothing is going to change the fact it's a brick wall. I have learned that if you do end up punching the wall, thank the wall for the reality check that it was stupid to do that in the first place.

I sued a company for 88k. It cost me 10k up front and the company offered me 65k and the lawyer told me to take it as I would loose another 10k just to move to trial.

But I stood strong and said, send a letter to them that says, I've already lost 88k, that means my lawyer bills can get to 88k and I didnt loose anything but you "the company I sued", will spend 176k for a 88k issue.

They resent it for 83k which was "fair". But all said and done, I only got 73k from 88k worth of invoives.

Then 3 months later as I got my last check, the company asked me to go back. I said sure, I was COD and the first invoice will include the remainder of the balance of the lawsuit. They never called me back.

Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk
 
This happens to me about twice a year.

What I have found to do is to treat them just like they treat you. Meaning dont use the pointy finger saying YOU DID THIS. That doesn't help, usually.

This can take up to 6 months to complete, but it is way, way cheaper then a lawyer or loosing all the work time.

And dont just flip out getting mad at them. That usually doesnt end well and usually hurts your chance of getting any money. You also loose some of yourself getting so mad at things out of your control. For example, dont be mad, punch a brick wall, then get mad that the brick wall fucked your hand up and punch the wall again. Nothing is going to change the fact it's a brick wall. I have learned that if you do end up punching the wall, thank the wall for the reality check that it was stupid to do that in the first place.

I sued a company for 88k. It cost me 10k up front and the company offered me 65k and the lawyer told me to take it as I would loose another 10k just to move to trial.

But I stood strong and said, send a letter to them that says, I've already lost 88k, that means my lawyer feels can get to 88k and I didnt loose anything but you "the company I sued", will spend 176k for a 88k issue.

They resent it for 83k which was "fair". But all said and done, I only got 73k from 88k worth of invoives.

Then 3 months later as I got my last check, the company asked me to go back. I said sure, I was COD and the first invoice will include the remainder of the balance of the lawsuit. They never called me back.

Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

I have to reply quick to this one. My grandfather rebuilt a machine for a major corporation down the street. Say $30k many many decades ago. Company went "bankrupt". They continued to run 3 shifts a day and never shut the lights off or changed the name on the sign. He got offered something like 6 cents on the dollar. He declined.

Problem for them was, his shop did all their rush maintenance work. Anytime there was an emergency they brought it to his shop. I worked at his shop nearly 20 years after this happened. Guy brought in a bent shaft. The whole production line was down. Took maybe 5 minutes while the guy watched to straighten the shaft. Charged them $300 for those 5 minutes.

On every invoice he would put a note with the remaining balance from that job including interest.
 
The way I see it is that most well organized companies have very formal processes in place to recieve material into their facility and then properly move the items to where they are needed efficiently. Once all is said and done these systems also ensure vendors get paid for goods sent.

It seems like to me you went outside of this normal process and just randomly dropped a package into their facility without the proper people ever giving or creating a record that it was recieved, and accidentally made a mess out of things all the while trying to be a great guy. It doesn't take much imagination to see this same thing happening where I work or any well organized company with more than say 40 employees that buy and recieve a lot of materials every day.

As others have mentioned you really need to calmly reach out to the guy who solicited you and explain what happened and ask him how to help fix things make sure things go smoother next time. I suspect once you learn how to properly deliver items to this facility hopefully things will go a lot smoother in the future.

Sent from my SM-J737V using Tapatalk
 
QUOTE] by OP

I have found as I have gotten older my patience has rapidly evaporated. People's incompetency and general stupidity has pushed me to the point where I am 100% full boil instantly. I spend probably more time than reasonable double, triple, and sometimes quadruple checking my work. Verifying all aspects to guarantee that my work, or whatever I am doing is correct. When I make a mistake I am proactive, I take care of it before anyone knows it exists. When I fail to identify a mistake before someone else identifies the mistake, when that mistake is identified, everything in my life comes to a stop until that mistake is corrected. QUOTE]

I love this paragraph - well said!
 
Wow, what a mess.
Best not to do the get all mad thing. Sometimes this just a bookkeeping mess up and it is how do we straighten out the paperwork.
Other times there are crooks that deserve death.
If inside small claims limits you do not need a lawyer and it actually rather simple here.
Here is the but...they do not show up and you win the judgment. Getting the actual money into your checking account a very different story and more cost.
I know your pain, frustration and the crazy rage one feels inside. How does one let that go?

Calmer heads. Here is the paperwork on my side. This is what I believe you owe me.
Bob
 
I have to reply quick to this one. My grandfather rebuilt a machine for a major corporation down the street. Say $30k many many decades ago. Company went "bankrupt". They continued to run 3 shifts a day and never shut the lights off or changed the name on the sign. He got offered something like 6 cents on the dollar. He declined.

Problem for them was, his shop did all their rush maintenance work. Anytime there was an emergency they brought it to his shop. I worked at his shop nearly 20 years after this happened. Guy brought in a bent shaft. The whole production line was down. Took maybe 5 minutes while the guy watched to straighten the shaft. Charged them $300 for those 5 minutes.

On every invoice he would put a note with the remaining balance from that job including interest.

good story, and.. well a perfect object lesson.

never forget your anger costs YOU some of your health and sanity. there is an infinite volume of things to get angry at.

having a quick trigger and assuming malice when it is actually mere run of the mill incompetence doesn't do you any good and actually hurts your chances of getting what you want in the end. trust the boss (wife) on this one!
 
This is why nothing leaves my shop before it is paid for! Sorry Fal, I know that doesn't help.
But us little guys can't be dicking around with these stupid money games. And, I am just like you. Screw me? I go instant full-boil! :mad5:
I am probably one of the least passive people you could ever meet.

I've told this story on here before: I got over 120 days out once in the beginning, and knew where the "accounts" lady's desk was.
Happened to be right up front with a picture window. I parked my truck 8ft behind her back. I saw her sitting there when I parked.
She had been ignoring me for a while at this time.
I barged in guns blazing. Went right through the do not enter sign. Straight to her desk. And in my "big-voice" said:
"Turn around, see that truck?! If you don't cut me a check right now I'm going to park that Mother-'effer on this got-damn desk!"
By now the boss had showed up, and nicely asked her if they owed me money. She got out "yes, but" and he interrupted with "what date were we invoiced?"
She told him. And he sternly said "cut the check" and walked out. I snatched it out of her hand with a scowl. No words. And left as fast as I showed up.
That place kept sending me RFQ's occasionally for a year or two. I always rejected. They eventually got the hint.

That's a fun story, but that will get you thrown in jail.

The moral of the story is to get to the person with the decision making power with the right info.
 
At my last location I had a Jewish neighbour who's business was installing large Christmas trees at SoCal Malls and some Indian casinos, think 60'+ tall trees etc.

One of his installers was an ex Huntington Beach Neo-Nazi skinhead, covered in Nazi tats. Apparently he was a nice guy, but a Scary looking dude. Everytime my late German wife would see him she would dive under the tables.

Every time my Jewish neighbour had trouble getting paid he'd send this guy around. Only ever took one visit to get paid.
 
Unlike thermie,I dont personally know any Triad,but I did have a bunch of bikies who would buy debt at 50c/dollar..........the importance of selling the debt ,legally,with paperwork,is if the bikies get carried away,you can show the cops it wasnt on your instructions.
 
I would call your contact you made the parts for, see if he is at work then drive over there and visit in person with intent of being nice and trying to figure out what went wrong. If you don't think you can do that and will get the cops called, then maybe don't drive over there. I think an in person conversation could fix it quickly and maybe even take a check home.

I learned a few things the hard way when a buddy and I partnered up to make a few things and we sold one to a guy in another state. Partner knew the guy so we shipped it with expectation of payment when he got it. It went UPS, my buddy dropped it off at the local store who boxed it up for him and sent it. Months go by and no payment, find out that the thing was damaged in shipment so the guy wasn't going to pay for it. We went to file a claim with UPS and I found out the shipper was the local store not us, so we had to get our money from the store. What a nightmare, we did ALL the things wrong. I spent many many hours chasing $500, it took almost 9 months before I got my money back. I stopped in at the UPS store almost everyday there for awhile and the owner acted like she didn't know who I was everytime I went in there. I spent so much time and effort getting paid for that, that I lost all interest in the business. It was a side gig with intent to make it full time, but I put my energy and emotion into getting paid for that one thing that I just didn't have it in me to continue and to this day have not made any more of those. I still have parts to put more together, but just can't get excited about it. This was in 2004 or so.

I have since be on my own doing other things, but the one thing I try to remember is to not let stupid things like this ruin my life. I have done all I can to make sure that I don't get screwed, but I have been slow payed a few times. The one that did it to me twice is a no quote now. They are local and I stopped by a few times and let them know I was still unpaid etc. I think it helped.

My biggest customer when I started is a pretty big one with multiple branch stores and all their payments come from the home office. When I first started I went a few months without getting paid. Local manager had helped me more than once in the past so I was trying to not get worked up about it. Ultimately it was a matter of the paperwork. I wasn't in their system yet, the person that did that had gotten sick etc, there were multiple stupid things that delayed them paying me. I toughed it out with advice from the local guy and once they got me setup and paid that first time, I never had anymore problems in the time since.
 
You got an order to make some parts in early December, and [not knowing you ship date] you are already all up in arms about this?
(I understand that wasn't your terms)

You have called the customer's people names?

Other than this accounting concern, any reason that you wouldn't want to continue with them?
I wouldn't want to continue with YOU if I was them anymore.

Flying off the handle seldom does anyone any good.

At least one person above posted this - but if you were fit to be tied about anything,you should have contacted your buyer.
That is THE person that wants to keep you happy! (and knows your history)


I've said this many times in the past, but the mindset on this forum is always that you are going to git screwed by the customer, and I understand your concerns. But y'all seem to miss the other side of that.... You [the customer] just received in a skid of parts from Small Shop. You paid him COD, and he left. Now you find that the parts won't make it through QC. You call Small Shop guy, and he doesn't want to rework or completely re-run the job again, and maybe can't even afford to.

When you sell a made-to-order part, someone is taking a risk. Either you for getting paid, or them for it actually being what they asked for.
There really is no middle ground.

Yeah, the gun industry runs on COD. The rest of the world doesn't.
However, I don't think that lack of funds is really a major concern right now?
Business has issues with getting help, but not with getting work. So it's not like they have a large staff that they are trying to payroll for and don't have the ability to fund that.
Also - with interest rates so low, there is very little incentive to hold funds.

AND - with the issues of getting help, if you find an outside source that can fill your needs, you are going to doo everything that you can to keep that source on your side!

Of course you could always get screwed, but this is not the environment rich with that issue right now, and you just proved to not be someone that is at the top of that customers list to call on anymore. Hopefully that was worth it to you.


---------------------

Think Snow Eh!
Ox
 
At my last location I had a Jewish neighbour who's business was installing large Christmas trees at SoCal Malls and some Indian casinos, think 60'+ tall trees etc.

One of his installers was an ex Huntington Beach Neo-Nazi skinhead, covered in Nazi tats. Apparently he was a nice guy, but a Scary looking dude. Everytime my late German wife would see him she would dive under the tables.

Every time my Jewish neighbour had trouble getting paid he'd send this guy around. Only ever took one visit to get paid.

This story has everything needed for an old joke: A Jew, a Neo-Nazi skinhead and a German wife - they were all sitting at a bar.......
 
At least one person above posted this - but if you were fit to be tied about anything, you should have contacted your buyer.

I would call your contact you made the parts for

As others have mentioned you really need to calmly reach out to the guy who solicited you

As I stated in the initial post, he was called, calmly and politely. In fact, multiple times, never answered the phone calls or returned the voice mails left. He also has not responded to the emails that were sent directly to him, nor the emails that he was copied on.

So to everyone that says, you should have contacted your buyer, I did. I didn't flip out on this over night. While I have a short temper for incompetence, that incompetence took over 4 weeks to prove out. Their invoice is now 5 weeks over due.

You got an order to make some parts in early December, and [not knowing you ship date] you are already all up in arms about this?
Order was placed 11/29 with a due date of 12/10, including design, grinding custom form tooling, etc etc. Do you make a habit of delivering 5 weeks late? I sure don't. A business deal is a two way street. I meet your terms, you meet mine. Done and done. You don't want to do business with me because I hold you to the terms you agreed to, that is fine by me. I'll always meet or exceed mine.

You have called the customer's people names?
Ox why would I call the customers people's names? Are they incompetent, absolutely. Are they idiots, probably. But I did manage to get out of my folks house with at least a basic enough education to know not to call people names. I might be stupid, but I know that insulting the person I am trying to convince to do their job is going to have a negative outcome.

It seems like to me you went outside of this normal process and just randomly dropped a package into their facility
The entire process was outside their normal processes. They couldn't get the job done through their normal processes. If you ask me to do a job outside your normal processes, I expect you to accommodate me outside those normal processes. They had no problem receiving the parts. They were received, and they were marked received, per the AP woman. As I stated in my initial post, the problem was the invoice was not submitted.

Probably 90% of my business is "outside normal processes". No PO, CC payment, rush work, high tolerance or weird features, we are not quite sure what we need, etc.

I suspect once you learn how to properly deliver items to this facility hopefully things will go a lot smoother in the future.

I won't have to worry about meeting their delivery procedures. In the future I won't be a nice guy. They will make the hour and a half round trip, hand me a check, pick up their items, and go. That part has definitely been straightened out!

Did you ever tell us the amount of money involved here?
No, a little less than $4k. Pocket change for the way a lot of folks boast on here. For me that is a big chunk of change.
 
You paid him COD, and he left. Now you find that the parts won't make it through QC. You call Small Shop guy, and he doesn't want to rework or completely re-run the job again, and maybe can't even afford to.

Three times now in over 9 years, I have replaced an entire run of parts. One was 2,000pcs. That one stung.

Yeah, the gun industry runs on COD. The rest of the world doesn't.

Welcome to my catch-22 (I'm not even a gun-guy).

Also - with interest rates so low, there is very little incentive to hold funds.
Think Snow Eh!
Ox

I'm still trying to figure out the reality of this one!
In the automotive aftermarket for sure, there is a huge trend right now of companies basically pre-selling what would normally be a whole run of product.
Before they even start. Its not like they take your info, and wait until shipping to charge your card.
You will pay full price to even get on the list.
Yukon Free-spin hubs (you know the ones), I would buy another set right now. But they told me 6 months out after payment.
That is just one example. I've seen several more with the exact same situation. There has to be more to this.
 
That's a fun story, but that will get you thrown in jail.

The moral of the story is to get to the person with the decision making power with the right info.

I felt like a complete A-hole for a while afterwards! The drive home was miserable, LOL.
But, it was in my infancy. And, I had a machine payment due, and was broke. And, as mentioned: crazy hot temper.
The real problem was: all contact to this place goes through that lady. So, short of having somebodies personal cell? She is all you got.
When I got the first RFQ from them after that, I felt a little better.
 
Ox why would I call the customers people's names? Are they incompetent, absolutely. Are they idiots, probably. But I did manage to get out of my folks house with at least a basic enough education to know not to call people names. I might be stupid, but I know that insulting the person I am trying to convince to do their job is going to have a negative outcome.





I've had my shop now 12 years, and 6 of that it has been my "full time" job.

In that 12 years, this is the first time I have been burned by a non-paying customer. Well, they sorta paid.

In July of 2021 a company approached me to do some really strange work, in an industry that I have never done work in before. They spent several weeks trying to find a shop to manufacture the small quantity, very specialty work, in a VERY short lead time. Ie, 4 parts, completely bastard everything, worthless drawing, they don't know exactly what it is they need, but they needed it two weeks ago.

I have a policy that new customers pay 50% upfront and 50% on completion. That worked fine for them because they didn't have time to formally submit everything and get a PO made. They paid the 50% down with a CC and I got started. I got the parts done, early, (worked over July 4th weekend and on July 4th) and told them to make the payment and they could pick up the parts. To save the 3% CC fee they asked if they could bring a check. No problem. They bring a check for the full amount, pick up the parts, no issues.

Beginning of December they reach out and say that they need another batch of parts made. A different bastard part, same conditions. They say it has to be run through a PO this time. I submit a quote, but since they are a repeat customer, terms are now payment on completion. They say great. Even after some issues with their worthless drawing and specs I get the parts made.

Here is where I am an idiot, and everything falls apart. They are about 45 minutes away, and I happened to be driving by. So I dropped off the parts, saving them an hour and a half drive. The guy I deal with isn't there. No-one else knows anything about the parts. So I call the guy and he says yea great, leave them with so and so. It's a Friday afternoon, no-one is there to cut me a check.

Some of you are either laughing or yelling at the computer screen like a bad horror movie.

In some ways I lucked out a little bit. The companies AP department reached out to me for a W-9, so they gave me their own information. When the invoice got to be 2 weeks late I called and explained who I was and the woman on the phone was very polite and apologized for the payment not being made. Seems the guy who wrote the PO and ordered the parts marked them as delivered, but did not submit the invoice. I emailed her another copy of the invoice, and while on the phone she confirmed that she received the invoice. She said they would run a check the next batch and have it out to me.

2 weeks later I still had not received payment. So I sent emails out again and she responded that she had no invoice and even included a nice screen shot of her computer system showing that there was no invoice due.
I had started to email her back that she was incompetent and I don't enter invoices into their systems, that's her job, and she confirmed she had the invoice so clearly she didn't do her job. My wife intervened and typed her a short and terse email in AP/AR jargon explaining that she was incompetent and didn't do her job, but in business speak. I got an email that afternoon that a check would be cut the next run(probably friday).

The following monday a check arrives in the mail. Hooray.

But wait....

There's more!

The check is for just over half of the invoiced amount.

I have found as I have gotten older my patience has rapidly evaporated. People's incompetency and general stupidity has pushed me to the point where I am 100% full boil instantly. I spend probably more time than reasonable double, triple, and sometimes quadruple checking my work. Verifying all aspects to guarantee that my work, or whatever I am doing is correct. When I make a mistake I am proactive, I take care of it before anyone knows it exists. When I fail to identify a mistake before someone else identifies the mistake, when that mistake is identified, everything in my life comes to a stop until that mistake is corrected.

Immediately upon looking at the check I am pissed, beyond pissed. I bent over backwards to get this company what they needed, I was a nice guy and went out of my way to save them an hour and a half drive, I did the work that half a dozen machine shops wouldn't attempt, and they screwed me. I already had my phone out trying to decide whether to call in a tactical missile strike or nuke the whole place into oblivion and walk away from it all together. My wife took the check from me and looked it over.

Thirty seconds later she says, this is a deduction, they deducted from your invoice.

WTF does that mean!

It means they think you owe them money, so they deducted that from your invoice.

Sure enough we sat down at the computer and looked up the two previous invoices for this company, and low and behold, they deducted the two previous invoice amounts from this invoice.

So, now, what the heck do I do? My wife once again saved my hide and wrote another email to the AP lady explaining that they had an unauthorized deduction without providing any backup or explanation, and further the deduction was not approved and never discussed and they would need to submit full payment.

That was monday. No one is responding to phone calls or answering emails. The "Operations Manager" who I usually communicate with is not answering his phone, AP lady is not answering her phone, and no one that I have email addresses for are responding.

My wife explained to me that the AP People are like robots. Stupid robots I asked? They just process the information. If the information they are given is incomplete or incorrect, it still gets processed. Hmmm stupid programmer then. No, they just work within the confines of their task. Some companies give their AP department a lot of room to look at and do things, other companies do not. She thinks once they look to provide backup, they will find that there is none, and make complete payment.

I do not think for a second that they will.

So my immediate thought is Small Claims court. Any thoughts, opinions, experiences? Is it worth my time? When they get a summons will they show up with a big shot lawyer? Maybe... at this point they are going to spend the money they owe me one way or another.


I missed the part that that you didn't send it, but apparently you did not actually learn that:

"insulting the person I am trying to convince to do their job"

is a bad thing, but apparently your wife did learn that?
I also took it that her mail was not so nice, but I take it from your rebuttal that she "honey'd it up" a bit.


Communications are terrible right now for sure tho.
You had the holidays in there, and now it seems that EVERYONE is home sick!
And those that ARE there are running around and picking up loose ends everywhere.
Many people are not in their own jobs,and are covering for others.

The furnace brazing outfit that I use near here was running on 1/2 crew for the last cpl'a weeks.
I think that they are pretty much up and running now tho.
(my parts got done)

I have a customer up in Minnesota that has had several off.

I have another customer that is more local, and I haven't gotten any response from that direction to speak of in a while.
Purty sure that contact is out as well...

etc...


I doubt it's any different on your side of the state.
I also doubt that there was any malice intended.
Likely your guy is out?
And maybe the main A/P clerk is out as well?



Edit:

So, are you saying that you have not done anything to burn the bridge to this customer yet?
All the ranting a raving has been here, or at home, and you are just venting to us?
That's not what it sounded like, but maybe?

But the fact that we get the routine thread about "How doo I find Customers?" and then to read a post like this where there has clearly been mistakes made - and mostly b/c you are special and can't be bothered with standard accounting practices, you either have, have all but, or are clearly looking to burn this bridge.
The next time this guy is looking at a potential one-man-band that wants to make parts for him, he just may say "forget it'....

Enough so - that you are at 35 days, over the biggest holidays, during the biggest "sick" bought, in-amungst the worst employment surge - and you are fit to be tied?
Forget the fact that you DID get a check! Maybe the right hand doesn't know what the left did a few months ago, but it will come out in the worsh. Jist hold'ger britches on sonny!

Now, is a customer that normally pays at 30 or even 45 days (is anyone paying that late routinely these days?) not worth having?
Charge the price that you need to for the "special" work and attention, but when you start asking for special stuff in their office, and it doesn't work out, you can be disappointed, but don't be surprised.


-----------------------

One Man Band
Ox
 
Last edited:
Its got a lot to do with your attitude....if you accept bad payers and bad debts as just something that happens,it will happen a lot.......If you let the bad payer know for sure he s made a bad choice ,and back it up,its surprising how quickly the word spreads.......the habitual bad payers try their tricks on someone else .
 
I don't believe that that any large company with on staff accountents make any accidental payments that short venders. They play all kinds of games to delay payments even when they don't have to. How many times have any of you been over paid on any invoices?

One thing I got burned on was a bad check for $1,500. In Florida (when I was in business) any bad check over $50. was a felony punishable by jail time, except if it was for payment of a past due bill. Then the threshold was $50,000 before it became a felony. Payments by check for a past due bill are treated like a promissary note. So if you left someone with goods and did not get payment then you extended them credit. With nothing in writing it makes it hard to collect. Rules may differ from state to state but it is something to consider when extending credit.
 








 
Back
Top